Wheel of Fortune is in both estates 38 & 39 in St. Croix’s West End Quarter, with estate 38 being of interest on this page. Based on appearances on historic maps, the animal mill was likely built by 1750.
The first sign of settlement on historic maps in estate 38 is the animal mill on the 1750 map. While the animal mill does not appear on the first Beck printing, it does appear on the second printing. Most of the later variants of the Beck map included an animal mill, although the Küffner map only indicates a settlement. The 1767 annotated Beck map has the animal mill scratched out. None of the maps from the 1778 Oxholm map and later show any structures in estate 38, with any sugar processing likely moved east to the other part of Wheel of Fortune.
Ownership attribution in 1750 is to the widow Schempen. The 1766 Beck variants name John Willet, while the 1767 and 1770 variants name Joergen Hardung. The 1778 Oxholm map attributed ownership to Hardung’s heirs. By the 1790s ownership transitioned simply to Hardung.
McGuire geographic dictionary of the Virgin Islands (p. 198) notes Wheel of Fortune combined with a number of other estates and was nearly all in sugar cane in the 1920s.