Orange Grove is estate 8 in St. Croix’s Prince’s Quarter. Based on appearances on historic maps, the animal mill was likely built in the late 1750s or early 1760s.
The earliest sign of settlement in the estate 8 in Prince’s Quarter portion of Orange Grove was on the 1766 annotated Beck map, where an animal mill appears. The animal mill also appears in estate 8 on the 1767 annotated map and the 2 manuscript copies of Beck of 1766. No structures appear in estate 8 on Oxholm or Parsons or the subsequent maps, suggesting that the animal mill icon appears in estate 8 in error, rather than estate 31 of West End Quarter.
All the Beck variations attributed ownership to James Mead. By 1790, ownership transitioned to Taite Armstrong.
McGuire geographic dictionary of the Virgin Islands (p.140) notes that the village is in the valley, which lies in the West End Quarter portion of the joint estate, and that guavas grow wild. In the 1850s, the Scorpion survey used for Parsons map attributed ownership to Kelly.